Interpretation **** Sound Quality **** Repertoire Value *** Booklet ***
“…Wilson gives the pieces everything they need to develop their effect: nonchalance and lively dynamics, precisely dosed sentiment and a feel for the late romantic timbres. The BBC Philharmonic responds flexibly to the conductor's intentions and refines them with a luxurious sound. The introductory text in the trilingual booklet humorously describes the musical background of the pieces in the context of Eric Coates' personal circumstances. The soundly immaculately prepared recording is a carefree acoustic pleasure and is just plain fun to listen to.”
Karin Cooper – Klassik.com – 2 March 2021
“… The playing by the BBC Philharmonic on this recording is very good indeed, and it is ably led by John Wilson … The Chandos recording is also very good …”
William Kempster – Fanfare – May/June 2021
“… I thoroughly enjoyed these excellent performances…”
Elliot Fisch – American Record Guide – March/April 2021
“… Volume 2 of John Wilson’s traversal maintains the charms of its predecessor, with Wilson and his BBC forces capturing every nuance of these wonderful scores.” ****½
Greg Keane – Limelightmagazine.com.au – 6 January 2021
“… Brilliant performances.” *****
Oliver Condy – BBC Music magazine (Brief Notes Section) – January 2021
“…John Wilson zips through these readings that are as smart as new paint, while the 1938 ballets score The Enchanted Garden shows – say, the charming Allegretto, No. 4, with its swooning second theme what a master of orchestral colour Coates was…” Sound 90%
Christopher Breunig – Hi-Fi News.com – 18 December 2020
Best Albums of 2020
“John Wilson has made some first-class recordings this year. I especially like the second volume of his Eric Coates Orchestral Works.”
David Mellor – Daily Mail – 5 December 2020
“… The BBC Philharmonic’s performance under the baton of John Wilson is perfect. It is always good to hear Coates’s music played well, and without any condescension. The liner notes, by Richard Bratby provide all the information needed to add value to this CD…”
John France – MusicWeb-International.com – 19 November 2020
“… if Elgar (sometimes) summoned images of Empire, Coates was a man of the English town and countryside; and this second volume of John Wilson’s latest survey of the orchestral works offers beautifully played and knowingly paced renditions of some gorgeous pieces … A terrific disc, then, and a delectable appetiser for Vol. 3”
Rob Cowan – Gramophone magazine – November 2020
“A fine selection of pieces, played and directed with relish.”
Jonathan Woolf – MusicWeb-International.com – 23 October 2020
“…Wilson has been a Coates champion for decades and has the natural lightness of touch to make these works, including a substantial ballet, The Enchanted Garden, and an Oscar Wilde-based phantasy, The Selfish Giant, sparkle.”
Hugh Canning – The Sunday Times (Culture magazine) – 4 October 2020
Recommended
“… Volume 1 simply had to be Recommended; so, too, must this. More, please.”
Brian Wilson – MusicWeb-International.com – 21 September 2020